Blog · Governance · 5 min read
Treating Owners Alike: Fairness and Consistency in BC Strata Decisions
ManageStrata Team
November 14, 2026

Two owners hang the same style of awning off the same style of balcony. One gets a letter and a fine; the other has had theirs up for three years and has never heard a word. At the next council meeting, nobody can find the file on either one — just a vague memory that the older awning was "grandfathered" by a council three terms ago.
The problem isn't really the awning. It's that the decision trail isn't visible, so two owners in the same position were treated differently and no one can explain why. This post covers what the Strata Property Act actually requires before a council enforces a bylaw, what "significantly unfair" means in BC strata law, and the habits that keep a council consistent.
Consistency is a record-keeping problem before it is a legal one
Most selective-enforcement complaints are not malice. They are memory. A council that handles complaints by email thread and recollection will inevitably treat similar facts differently, because nobody can see the earlier file. A council that writes down the complaint, the response, the decision and the reason can answer the question an owner is really asking: what did you do the last time this came up?
That is why fairness and openness are the same commitment. When every owner can see the same record, there is far less to argue about — and when a decision genuinely was different, the record shows the reason it was different.
The statutory floor: section 135
Before a strata corporation imposes a fine, requires someone to pay the costs of remedying a contravention, or denies the use of a recreational facility, section 135 requires all of the following:
- the strata has received a complaint about the contravention;
- the owner or tenant has been given the particulars of the complaint in writing and a reasonable opportunity to answer it, including a hearing if they request one;
- if the person is a tenant, notice of the complaint has gone to the landlord and the owner; and
- written notice of the decision, given as soon as feasible.
These are the three enforcement tools the Act gives a strata: a fine under s.130, remedying the contravention and charging the reasonable costs under s.133, or denying access to a recreational facility for a reasonable length of time under s.134. Under s.129, a council may also simply warn the person or give them time to comply.
Two points councils get caught on. First, the s.135 steps cannot be done after the fact to rescue a fine already imposed — the process has to come first. Second, once the strata has complied for a contravention of a particular bylaw or rule, s.135(3) allows it to fine for a continuing contravention of that same bylaw without repeating the whole process.
And if the complaint is about a council member, s.136 says that member must not participate in the s.135 decision about it — unless all the owners are on council.
Questions councils and owners actually ask
Is it illegal to enforce a bylaw against one owner and not another?
The Act does not use the phrase "selective enforcement." What it does give an owner or tenant is a remedy for a significantly unfair action or decision of the strata corporation, including council, under s.164 — and the Civil Resolution Tribunal also handles most strata disputes of this kind. Inconsistent treatment of owners in materially similar situations is a common ingredient in those claims. Whether any particular pattern crosses the line depends on the facts.
Can an owner appeal a council decision at the AGM?
No. There is no statutory right of appeal to a general meeting. What the Act provides is s.34.1: an owner or tenant may request a hearing at a council meeting by written application stating the reason. Council must hold the meeting within 4 weeks, and if the purpose is to seek a decision, must give a written decision within one week of the hearing. After that, the routes are the CRT or the courts.
Does a past council's leniency bind us forever?
The Act doesn't say. Practically, a council can begin enforcing a bylaw it previously let slide — but doing it to one owner while ignoring others is exactly the pattern that invites a significant-unfairness claim. A cleaner approach is a written, dated decision to begin enforcing a bylaw corporation-wide, communicated to all owners first.
Can we just make a new rule instead?
Rules and bylaws are different instruments with different reach and different approval paths — see Strata Bylaws vs Rules in BC before choosing one.
Build consistency into the process, not the personalities
- Log every complaint the same way: date received, bylaw or rule cited, who was notified, response received, decision, reason.
- Use a standard particulars letter so no owner gets less information than another.
- Decide at a council meeting and minute the decision, not in a side conversation. Clear minutes are the memory of the corporation — see How to Prepare AGM Minutes in BC.
- Check precedent before deciding. If your bylaw file and past decisions are a decade of scanned PDFs, a tool like SearchStrata can help a council find what the registered bylaws and prior decisions actually say before the vote, rather than after the complaint.
- Remember who may sit on council: under s.28, generally owners, individuals representing corporate owners, and tenants assigned that right — though a strata may widen this by bylaw.
Whether your strata is self-managed or works with a property manager, the duty to follow s.135 and to treat owners alike belongs to the corporation either way.
What a healthy strata does about it
A healthy strata decides the same question the same way twice, and can show why. Complaints are logged, particulars go out in writing, hearings happen when asked for, decisions are minuted with reasons, and owners can see the history that applies to them. Nothing important lives only in one person's inbox.
That is also why the record should stay with the corporation. Councils turn over, managers change, and the next council inherits either a searchable history or a shrug. ManageStrata is built on that premise: the documents, minutes, votes and books belong to the strata corporation, stay when the council or manager changes, and council can export a full copy at any time.
This article is general information about BC strata law, not legal advice; verify against the current Strata Property Act and Regulation or consult a BC strata lawyer.
General information, not legal advice. This article explains British Columbia strata law in general terms. The Strata Property Act and its regulations change over time and apply differently to each strata corporation. Confirm details against the current legislation or consult a qualified strata lawyer before acting.
Frequently asked questions
- What does "significantly unfair" mean for a BC strata decision?
- Section 164 of the Strata Property Act lets the Supreme Court make orders to prevent or remedy a significantly unfair action, threatened action or decision of the strata corporation, including council, in relation to an owner or tenant — and the Civil Resolution Tribunal handles most strata disputes of this kind. Inconsistent treatment of owners in materially similar circumstances, or a decision made without the process the Act requires, is often part of such a claim, but whether any specific decision qualifies turns on the facts.
- What must a strata council do before issuing a fine?
- Under s.135, the strata must have received a complaint, given the owner or tenant written particulars of the complaint and a reasonable opportunity to answer it (including a hearing if requested), notified the landlord and owner if the person is a tenant, and then given written notice of the decision as soon as feasible. These steps must come before the fine; doing them afterwards does not validate a fine already imposed. Once the strata has complied for a contravention of that bylaw or rule, it may fine for a continuing contravention without repeating the process.
- How does an owner challenge a council decision they think is unfair?
- Start with s.34.1: apply in writing stating the reason, and council must hold a hearing at a council meeting within 4 weeks, with a written decision within one week if the purpose is to seek a decision. There is no right to appeal a council decision at an AGM or SGM. If the hearing does not resolve it, the remaining routes are the Civil Resolution Tribunal or the courts, including a significant-unfairness claim under s.164.
Keep reading
Free guide · 18 pages
Your first term on the strata council
New to the council, or handing the job to someone who is? Ten short chapters on what a BC council actually does, and the deadlines it can’t miss.
A few notes a year on running a strata
Deadlines that catch councils out, what changed in the rules, and what we shipped. Unsubscribe in one click, any time.
Run your strata with confidence
ManageStrata tracks your compliance deadlines, AGMs, and finances — with AI that drafts the work and you approve it. Self-managed or with a manager, the record stays with your corporation. Free up to 4 lots.
Start free